About


My name is Ardis and I am an avid reader and budding writer. I want to share my love of books with others. I work with kids and am interested in finding and creating books that will ignite the reader in everyone. Contact me at: ardis.atkins@gmail.com

Follow Me

Follow

Followers

Powered by Blogger.

Blog Archive

MsArdychan's bookshelf: read

I Owe You One
The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society
Love, Hate & Other Filters
The Wartime Sisters
The Belles
The Gilded Wolves
Hey, Kiddo
Blackberry and Wild Rose
Queen of Air and Darkness
Firestarter
The Retribution of Mara Dyer
The Evolution of Mara Dyer


MsArdychan's favorite books »

Total Views

Showing posts with label YA Dystopian. Show all posts
Showing posts with label YA Dystopian. Show all posts
Saturday, November 20, 2021

ARC Review: Generation Manifestation by Steven Bereznai



Please Note:  I received an advance copy of this novel from Edelweiss and the publisher in exchange for an honest review.  This did not influence the opinions in my review in any way.

Synopsis (from Goodreads):

TESTING DAY IS COMING.

The Genetic Wars that turned most of the planet into a wasteland are over. The so-called “dregs” (DNA regulars) and superpowered Supergenics now live separately from each other—the Supergenics in the shiny towers of Jupitar City; the dregs across the river in the squat concrete buildings of the boroughs. But some dreg parents bear Supergenic children; under repressive laws, they must be sent to live with their own kind.

THEY ARE GEN M.

To find these special few, every teen faces Testing Day. When her turn comes, socially isolated Caitlin Feral is determined to Manifest powers like the heroes in the comic book propaganda she loves. If she fails, she faces a lifetime of loneliness and drudgery in the boroughs.

How much is Caitlin willing to sacrifice to be a supergirl?

When she uncovers dark secrets, does she dare start another war to reveal the truth?

And…who will pay the price?

Find out in Generation Manifestation

Review:

It's been a while since I've read a dystopian YA novel.  And the dystopian world of Generation Manifestation is pretty bleak!  Several books have explored the idea of what it would be like if super-heroes were real.  But, most don't go down such a dark road.  Would people with superpowers be selfless and work to protect others?  Or, would they simply pull a Loki and take over?

via GIPHY



This book encompasses many elements of The Hunger Games, Divergent, and the X-Men.  What ties it all together is the main character, Caitlin, and her two friends, Bradie and Normand.  I enjoyed the world-building, characters, and the story.  There were a lot of twisty surprises in the story that kept me guessing, and made this a page-turner. 

What I Liked:

World-Building:

Generation Manifestation is set in a world where there are Supergenic people with various supernatural powers, and Dregs who do not.  It's a bleak world where the supergenics, who should be heroes, are more like the oppressors.  While they do protect the Dregs from mutated animals, the price they set is too high.  Supergenics get to live in a utopian city, while the Dregs get, well, the dregs.  They live a life of subsistence and dream of one day manifesting into a supergenic.  The Dregs' society is organized by the Protectorate.  This is a police force made up of Dregs who are talented athletes.  They are superhuman, but without the superpowers.   They also seem to have a power trip and are feared among the Dregs.

The author put much thought into how the society of this world would function.  Once a child manifests, they are whisked away to Jupiter City to (presumably) have a wonderful life as a Supergenic.  If you don't manifest be age sixteen, you are considered a Dreg.  Dregs are then put on a career track for menial jobs such as farm worker, garbage collector, techie, etc.  Some Dregs who are very fit, are recruited into the Protectorate.  This is the only path where regular people get a  chance at a better life.

Characters:

Caitlin, the main character has desperately wanted to be a Supergenic all her life.  Kids are tested once a year, and if by the time they're sixteen, if they don't "manifest", they are considered dregs.  When she starts trying out vocational jobs, like farmer, and protector, she realizes just how much privilege the protectors have, and is instantly seduced.  This is so understandable, since she has lived in poverty and near starvation for most of her life.  And being a protector is as close to being a Supergenic as she'll ever get.  But there's also a big price to pay when you have to enforce brutal laws...

Bradie is another proctor recruit, and he and Caitilin  are instantly attracted to each other.  Bradie's older brother is already a protector, so it's natural for Bradie to walk in his brother's footsteps.  But Bradie also has a deep resentment for the Protectorate.  Can he start a revolution and still keep the love of his brother?

Normand is a boy at Caitlin's school how seems rather strange.  He mutters to himself, and is obsessed with technology.  Caitlin starts to hang out with him when he shows her a massive (and illegal) comic book collection. He understands Caitlins obsession with becoming a supergenic.  And he encourages her to use her artistic skills to help him write a comic book.  Normand is a very complicated character, with lots of secrets.  It was fun to find out there is so much more to his character beyond nerdy tech bro.

Story:

While the world-building reminded me a lot of the Hunger Games, I could also so influences of Divergent and the X-Men in the story.  I think the story is about finding your own way to be a super human.  Whether that is by being lucky enough to have superpowers, or just embracing each opportunity, the characters are living fast.  With such an authoritarian regime, it's no wonder.

The story itself is obviously the start of a multi-book series.  We get a lot of backstory about how the Protectorate came to be, and how their society is set up.  I liked that Caitlin is a morally complicated character.  She is not perfect, and has to own up to the fact that while Bradie is incredibly handsome, it Normand who actually gets her.  She fluctuated between using Normand, and actually becoming his friend.

I do wish that some of Caitlin's other relationships, such as with her mother and brother, could have been addressed.  Near the beginning of the story, the mom kicks Caitlin out.  And then we never hear from her family again.  Maybe this is something that will be part of the next book in the series?  I hope so.


Rating:  ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Release Date:  September 14th, 2021

Author:  Steven Bereznai

Publisher:  Jambor

Genre:  YA Dystopian Novel

Page Length:  248 Pages

Source:  Edelweiss

Format:  E-Book

Recommendation:  A fun, YA dystopian novel.  The twists and turns of the story made this a highly entertaining book. 


SHARE ON: Share to Pinterest
Thursday, October 22, 2020

ARC Review: Winter, White and Wicked by Shannon Dittemore


 

Please Note:  I received an advance copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.  This did not influence the opinions in my review in any way.

 

Synopsis (from Goodreads):

Mad Max: Fury Road meets Frozen in this striking YA fantasy about a rig driver’s journey to save her friend
 
Twice-orphaned Sylvi has chipped out a niche for herself on Layce, an island cursed by eternal winter. Alone in her truck, she takes comfort in two things: the solitude of the roads and the favor of Winter, an icy spirit who has protected her since she was a child.
            Sylvi likes the road, where no one asks who her parents were or what she thinks of the rebels in the north. But when her best friend, Lenore, runs off with the rebels, Sylvi must make a haul too late in the season for a smuggler she wouldn’t normally work with, the infamous Mars Dresden. Alongside his team—Hyla, a giant warrior woman and Kyn, a boy with skin like stone—Sylvi will do whatever it takes to save her friend.
            But when the time comes, she’ll have to choose: safety, anonymity, and the favor of Winter—or the future of the island that she calls home.
  


Review:

When one reads the synopsis for Winter, White and Wicked, by Shannon Dittemore, you think, "Mad Max crossed with Frozen?"  But that is really the most apt description for this wonderfully strange mix of YA Dystopian and Fantasy.  In the scariest version of a road trip ever, Sylvi, the driver of a monster hauling vehicle, must drive a group of rebels across the frozen mountain pass, dodging monsters, impossible road conditions, and attacks by locals, all the while as she has Winter whispering truths (or is it lies?) about herself and her companions into her ears.  This was a really unusual, and entertaining book.


What I Liked:

Setting:

This novel is set in a snowy, dystopian landscape filled with monsters (many of which are human), terrible road conditions, and characters filled with secrets.  The area where Sylvi lives is in the control of The Majority, an oppressive regime who controls all the resources and keep people addicted to Kol, in order to manipulate them.  The region is in a perpetual winter.  But winter isn't just a season, it's a character in itself.  And she uses all her powers to manipulate and control Silvi.  But why...?

Characters:

Sylvi is a survivor.  She leaves a very abusive parent and is taken in by Lenore and her father.  She finally feels safe.  But when Lenore's father dies, and Lenore leaves to join the Rebels, her world (once again) is turned upside-down.  And she will do anything to regain that sense of security.  As the story progresses, you learn why she feels this way (trigger warning for sexual abuse).  In a world filled with people who want to use her, I don't blame her for her choices.

I loved Sylvi's companions on her road trip to find Lenore.  There is Hyla, a strong soldier who takes duty seriously.  I loved how she teaches all the characters about ethics, and sacrifice, while also kindness.  Mars Dresden, the rebel leader, is charasmatic, and persuasive.  But Sylvi can tell he's hiding something.  He wants Silvi to become a true believer in the rebel cause.  And he is trying, with all his might, to turn Sylvi against Winter.

Winter is an actual character.  She has befriended Sylvi and protected her when no one else has.  This created a strong bond between Sylvi and Winter.  If Sylvi betrays Winter, will she be all alone?  Will she be in danger?  

Road Trip:

I love a good road trip book.  But this is the road trip from Hell!  There are monsters, scary locals, and the ever-present thaw that could make driving the roads impossible.  Plus, as her "cargo" are rebels, they are on the run from military patrols who will kill them.  Everywhere they turn, someone wants them dead.  I loved how Silvi uses everything The Dragon has to keep the group going toward the rebel camp.  It was very Mcgyver as Sylvi pieces together spare parts in new ways to drive, fight, and fix machines.

 

TRIGGER WARNING FOR SEXUAL ASSAULT!

 

Rating: 



 

Release Date:  October 13th, 2020

Author:  Shannon Dittemore

Genre:  YA Dystopian Fantasy

Publisher:  Harry N. Abrams

Page Length:  384 Pages

Source:  NetGalley

Format:  E-Book

Recommendation:  A satisfying YA Dystopian story.  This is a world that is scary but has characters you will invest in.




SHARE ON: Share to Pinterest
Tuesday, September 29, 2020

Audio Arc Review: Skyhunter by Marie Lu

 


Please Note:  I received an advance audio copy of this book from Libro.fm and the publisher in exchange for an honest review.  This did not influence the opinions in my review in any way.


Synopsis (from Goodreads):

A broken world.
An overwhelming evil.
A team of warriors ready to strike back.


Talin is a Striker, a member of an elite fighting force that stands as the last defense for the only free nation in the world: Mara.

A refugee, Talin knows firsthand the horrors of the Federation, a world-dominating war machine responsible for destroying nation after nation with its terrifying army of mutant beasts known only as Ghosts.

But when a mysterious prisoner is brought from the front to Mara's capital, Talin senses there’s more to him than meets the eye. Is he a spy from the Federation? What secrets is he hiding?

Only one thing is clear: Talin is ready to fight to the death alongside her fellow Strikers for the only homeland she has left . . . with or without the boy who might just be the weapon to save—or destroy—them all.

Loyalty is life.

#1 New York Times-bestselling author Marie Lu is back with an adrenaline-laced novel about the lengths one warrior will go to fight for freedom and those she loves.

 

Review:

I think I've read nearly all of Marie Lu's books.  They are filled with adventure, strong characters, and dystopian angst.  While Skyhunter, her newest novel, has many similar elements, it has a fresh story.  What is missing, which I am actually happy about, is a sweeping romance.  Given that the fictional country of Mara is under siege, I appreciate that the characters are focused more on staying alive than falling in love.  That's not to say there aren't hints of love in the future.  But the book is more focused on the tragedies of war.  Add to this a wonderful narrator, and you have an entertaining good time.

 

What I Liked:

Narrator:

Natalie Naudus does a wonderful job with all the voices in this book, particularly Talin (the main character) and Constantine (the bad guy).  I especially like her voice for Contantine. It is so creepy!!!  But she is also wonderful at showing the disdain the Maran citizens show Talin.  The racism Talin faces throughout the book is subtle and palatable.

World-Building:

The world of Skyhunter is a world at war.  Talin and her mother are refugees.  As the Federation invades their homeland, they flee to Mara, only to face an ongoing siege.  There, they face discrimination, poverty, and the threat of even more violence.  There is a huge disconnect between wealthy Marans and refugees.  The wealthy live barricaded behind a huge wall, secure from the threats of the Federation, while refugees live in the crowded outer city.  Refugees also face food shortages, crime, with no possibility of  having the opportunity of using their natural gifts.  By keeping the refugees down, Mara is not utilizing everything they could to resist the Federation.

Characters:

Talin is a wonderfully powerful , brave character.  Just as Japanese-American who were held in internment camps, volunteered to defend The United States in WWII, Talin volunteers to train as a Striker to defend Mara from the Federation.  This shows such character and integrity to put her mistreatment aside to risk her life for a country who treats her so poorly.

Talin is also disciplined.  She trains constantly to become a better soldier.  Her friendships strangthen her fighting skills, as she works as a team member on the battlefield.  While she is attracted to a certain character, she knows this is no time for romance.

Red is a former Federation soldier who is about to be executed.  Talin sees that there is something more to him than meets the eye.  He is no ordinary soldier, and intervenes just before he is about to be killed.  He is, in fact, a Skyhunter, who has been genetically engineered to be a killing machine.  The Federation may have changed him physically, but he actively doesn't wish to kill others.  It takes him a while to trust Talin.  But as they are paired up to fight at the warfront, Red can see what a good person Talin is, despite being an effective killer.

 

I think this is what Red and Talin have most in common.  They are both conflicted about killing, even in war.  They know, all too well, the pain of losing a loved one.  They know what they are doing will cause incalculable suffering for the families of those they cut down.

Story:

This is a story of war.  A story of why people volunteer to fight.  It's not to get a free pass to kill others.  It's about defending your family, your values, your way of life.  This book in no way glorifies war.  What it does is helps the reader understand why people will sacrifice their lives in order to protect others.  This is definitely a book that is relevant to our times.

Rating: 



 

Release Date:  September 29, 2020

Author:  Marie Lu

Genre:  YA Dystopian

Audio Publisher: MacMillan Audio

Narrator:  Natalie Naudus

Audio Length:  11 Hours, 58 Minutes

Print Publisher:  Roaring Brook Press

Print Length:  384 Pages

Source:  Libro.fm

Format:  Audiobook

A word about audiobooks:  

 If you like audiobooks, and want to support Independent bookstores, please consider buying your audiobooks from Libro.fm.  The money you spend supports Independent bookstores and not Amazon. 

If you are interested, please click on my link.  When you sign up, you'll get a free audiobook:

 http://libro.fm/referral?rf_code=lfm75477

Full Disclosure:  I do earn audiobooks if you sign up.

 

  

SHARE ON: Share to Pinterest
Wednesday, July 8, 2020

ARC Review: Truelif3 by Jay Kristoff



Please Note:  I received an advance copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. This did not influence the opinions in my review in any way.

Synopsis (from Goodreads):
Best friends have become enemies. Lovers have become strangers. And deciding whose side you're on could be the difference between life and death. For Eve and Lemon, discovering the truth about themselves--and each other--was too much for their friendship to take. But with the country on the brink of a new world war--this time between the BioMaas swarm at CityHive and Daedalus's army at Megopolis, loyalties will be pushed to the brink, unlikely alliances will form and with them, betrayals. But the threat doesn't stop there, because the lifelikes are determined to access the program that will set every robot free, a task requiring both Eve and Ana, the girl she was created to replace. In the end, violent clashes and heartbreaking choices reveal the true heroes . . . and they may not be who you think they are.

Review:
I remember back in 2016, when I met Jay Kristoff (and Amie Kaufman) at a book signing at my local Barnes & Nobles.  I don't know what happened.  Maybe the bookstore hadn't bothered with any publicity.  But here were two Rock Star authors...and eight fans!  I kid you not.

What must have been terrible for Jay and Amie was a boon for those of us who showed up.  We were able to sit around for ninety minutes and just talk to these two wonderful people.  We talked about everything: books, politics ("What is going on with you Americans?" they asked), war.  It was an exhilarating conversation which made me into a life-long fan.

Jay's latest book is Truelif3, the last in a Dystopian trilogy that is part Mad Max, part road trip, and completely riveting.  I loved it.

What I Liked:
Setting:
The books are set in a post-apocalyptic wasteland called the Yousay (a clever riff on the good ol' U.S.of A), where city-states compete for resources.  One city is driven by technology to provide the Yousay with energy and innovations, while another relies heavily on genetic engineering to supply the other cities with food.  Both are rich playlands for the elite.  The majority of people, however, live in squalor, eking out a living on the scraps of the rich city-states, and dreaming of a better life.  The pollution is so pervasive that the Grand Canyon is filled with plastic trash! 

Characters:
Eve has only recently learned that she is a Lifelike, a replacement for Ana, the daughter of a genius inventor.  All her memories have been implanted.  This has severely messed her up!  She is now obsessed with finding Ana and destroying her.  In fact, most of the Lifelikes borderline psychotic.  While their bodies are that of young adults, they are emotionally immature, quick to anger, and obsession.

Lemonfresh, is a Deviant.  She's human, but has super-human powers, and can manipulate electricity.  What I love about this series is that the main characters change with each book.  Lemonfresh was only a side-kick in the first book.  I love how she becomes the focus of the second and third books.  She is sweet, kind, and an underdog.  You can't help but root for her!

I also like that more attention is paid to side characters such as The Preacher, Abraham, Solomon, and Cricket.  Each of them have complete story arcs, and makes the series full and satisfying.

Themes:
How much should we rely on technology?  In one city, the elite let technology do all the work so they can bliss out in virtual reality tanks.  Life is brutal for everyone else in the areas around the city.  They aspire to get this life for themselves, and will do anything to get it.  It's a classic tale of capitalism run amok.

In another city, cloning has been embraced.  Every person is genetically engineered to fulfill a narrow purpose in society.  They seem happy.  Everyone has enough to eat, and find satisfaction in their tasks.  But there is no individuality.  No choice.

One of the other strong themes explores the role of servitude (slavery) in society.  Machines have just enough conscious thought to know that they have no choices, doomed to do the bidding of humans.  The author really does a wonderful job of creating empathy with Solomon and Cricket, as they begin to realize they are slaves.

What I Was Mixed About:
My only gripe with this book is with the ending.  While most characters have logical and satisfying resolutions, Eve's is too abrupt.  Without any preamble, her personality changes.  Are there any consequences for her actions?  I wish there had been a deeper exploration into how she turned out.

Rating: 


Release Date:  June 30th, 2020

Author:  Jay Kristoff

Publisher:  Knopf Books for Young Readers

Genre:  YA Dystopian

Page Length:  480 pages

Source:  NetGalley

Format:  E-book

Recommendation:  A thrilling finale to an action-packed series.  A must read!


SHARE ON: Share to Pinterest
Monday, June 3, 2019

The Red Labyrinth by Meredith Tate

Please Note:  I received an advance copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.  This did not influence the opinions of my review in any way.

Synopsis (From Goodreads):
The massive labyrinth was built to protect Zadie Kalver's isolated desert town. Unfortunately, living in the maze's shadow makes her feel anything but safe. Even without its enchanted deathtraps and illusions, a mysterious killer named Dex lurks in its corridors, terrorizing anyone in his path.

But when Zadie's best friend vanishes into the labyrinth-and everyone mysteriously forgets he exists- completing the maze becomes her only hope of saving him. In desperation, Zadie bribes the only person who knows the safe path through-Dex-into forming a tenuous alliance.

Navigating a deadly garden, a lethal blood-filled hourglass, and other traps-with an untrustworthy murderer for her guide-Zadie's one wrong step from certain death. But with time running out before her friend (and secret crush) is lost forever, Zadie must reach the exit and find him. If Dex and the labyrinth don't kill her first.


Review:
I have very mixed feelings about this book.  On the one hand, I thought the dystopian world-building to be wonderfully creative.  The dynamics between people who are "skilled" and "blank" were very relatable to racial discrimination in real life.  How this society decided to ration out scarce resources was realistic (but infuriating).  But, however much I liked the idea of a labyrinth, with it's traps and puzzles, it didn't really have a logical function in the book.  There were a lot of unexplained elements that the reader was just expected to accept.  And the ending was quite unsatisfying.

What I Liked:

World-Building:  
The author created a whole society around the idea that the survivors of a plague have needed to band together to conserve the few resources they have left.  All of the original survivors each had a "skill" or super-power.  But, over the years, some people, called "blanks" are born without any skills.  The town elders have decided that those without "skills" are not useful and are thrown out of town into the desert.  There, they are preyed upon by unscrupulous people to sign contracts as indentured servants.  I found this system to be, sadly, something I could see happen if water became more precious than gold.

This sets up a system of first and second-class citizens where value is determined by what skills one has.  But are skills the only thing of importance about a person?  What about character, or family connections?  How strange that some of these same questions are part of the recent immigration debate here in the U.S.

The Story of The Town:
I really liked the characters and story lines of the townspeople.  There were many interesting secondary characters who I wanted to know more about.  The author made me emotionally engage with their struggles and concerns. 

What I Was Mixed About:
The Labyrinth:
The Sand Guardian is a magical being who tries to trick Zadie and Dex to prevent them from reaching the Stone Palace.  I thought the traps and puzzles were very creative.  But what was the point?  

Zadie tries to reach the palace because a force field has encased the town, trapping all the skilled citizens.  Only blanks can go through the force field without being killed.  But why have a giant killer maze when a force field could have been used to keep everyone away from the palace in the first place (blanks would have no reason to go the palace)?

What I Didn't Like:
Inconsistent logic:
When one is creating an original universe, there must be rules as to how the universe works.  Even if the rules are really far out (such as cats having superpowers), it's fine as long as the rules are consistent.

             
via GIPHY

The inconsistency that I found annoying was that the author gave different explanations as to why the skilled people had superpowers.  Was it magic or genetics?  This becomes important because the labyrinth, itself, is supposed to be powered by magic.  But what does the sand guardian gain by keeping the people from the palace?  That is a mystery that is never explained.

The Ending:
I don't think I'm giving anything away by revealing that Zadie does make it through the labyrinth.  

               
via GIPHY

But even though the main problem of the story was resolved, it was not very emotionally satisfying.  Suddenly, there was much more going on in the story, and I was left with more questions than answers.  I felt like this was just a big set up for a sequel.




Rating: 





Release Date:  June 4th, 2019

Author:  Meredith Tate

Publisher:  Flux Publishing

Genre:  YA Dystopian Fantasy

Page Length:  352 Pages

Source:  NetGalley

Format:  E-Book

Recommendation: Although there were some major holes in logic and plot, I did find this book to be a quick, escapist read.  This would be a better library selection than a purchase.
SHARE ON: Share to Pinterest
Tuesday, August 8, 2017

ARC Review: The List by Patricia Forde


https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/33846933-the-list
Please Note:  I received an advance reader's copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.  This did not influence the opinions of my review in any way
  Synopsis (From Goodreads):
In the city of Ark, speech is constrained to five hundred sanctioned words. Speak outside the approved lexicon and face banishment. The exceptions are the Wordsmith and his apprentice Letta, the keepers and archivists of all language in their post-apocalyptic, neo-medieval world.

On the death of her master, Letta is suddenly promoted to Wordsmith, charged with collecting and saving words. But when she uncovers a sinister plan to suppress language and rob Ark’s citizens of their power of speech, she realizes that it’s up to her to save not only words, but culture itself.


Review:
I have just finished this book and have VERY mixed feelings about it. On the one hand, I think The List, by Patricia Forde, is well-written and has a compelling main character.  But, for me, the plot had so serious logic problems.  It was also rather offensive, in parts.

What I Liked:
Characters:
Letta, the Wordsmith's apprentice, is the heart of the book.  She is an orphan who is taken in by Benjamin, the Wordsmith.  He is like a father to her, so when he disappears and is feared dead, Letta is devastated.  She is now the Wordsmith, and must collect and distribute the approved lists of 500 words that each person may use in daily life.  

I liked Letta and thought she was a kind, empathetic soul.  She, like the rest of her town (called Ark), is easily led by Noa (the town's leader).  But her eyes are opened when she helps a boy hid from the gavvers (police).  She was a bit naive, trusting the boy, Marlo, so easily.  But I think that most of the people in the town are very sheltered, and so this was plausible.  

I also liked Marlo and Finn, the two rebels.  They were not perfect people.  They justified violence and kidnapping in the name of rebellion.  But they also tried to talk Letta out of plans that would put her in danger.  I didn't feel they were using her, but that they actually cared for Letta.

No Forced Romance:
While the book hinted at an attraction between Letta and Marlo, it didn't get bogged down in the predictable romance trope.  At least during the length of the story, the characters have more important things to worry about than "Does he/she like me?"

Dystopian Society:
What would occur if the worst of global warming happens?  Massive floods, disruptions of society, and civil unrest could be the result.  In the book, what is left is an agrarian society that is tightly controlled by Noa.  He is a fanatic who believes that the root of all evil is language.  Somehow he believes that if people couldn't speak or communicate, they wouldn't destroy the earth.

The details of the set up of the society, with everything tightly controlled, including water and food being prepared in communal kitchens, was intriguing.  Censoring language seems probable in such a culture.  Other thing such as religion, marriage, books, and technology are also banned.


What I Didn't Like:
Plot Points:
Some of the plot points were problematic for me.  Noa, in an attempt to stop the use of language, cuts out the tongues of some of the children.  The book says that when this happened and they couldn't speak, they were driven to despair and killed themselves.  Such trauma may drive someone to commit suicide, but it didn't sit well with me that since they couldn't speak, they weren't able to communicate.  Lots of people can't speak, and learn other ways to communicate. 

Hasn't the author heard about sign language?  I happen to know children who are non-verbal and they are not in despair.  They use many methods to interact with others.  To suggest that not being able to access language in the same way as others would lead to despair is offensive to me.
 
The "wordless", as those who couldn't speak are called, could have developed a secret form of sign language or some other means to speak to each other.  That would have said more about the resiliency of the human spirit, and would have been a better message.

Logic issues:
Another problem with the plot involves the main problem.  Noa is going to poison the town with a chemical that would destroy the part of the brain that is used for language.  He confidently states that everyone, including future generations, will be free of the use of language from the poisoning.  Even if such a chemical did exist (and thankfully it doesn't), it wouldn't alter a person's DNA.  Any offspring would be unaffected.  This is basic genetics.  Surely Noa would be aware of that.

Plus, does he think that people wouldn't find alternate ways to communicate?  If they could not, they would have a tough time functioning as a society.  Also, wouldn't there be a panic and uprising when people wake up one day and suddenly can't communicate?  If he's trying to create a society that is harmless, this seems like a ridiculous approach.

For these reasons, I cannot recommend this book.

Rating: 




Release Date: August 1st, 2017

Genre:  YA Dystopian

Publisher:  Sourcebooks Jabberwocky

Length:  336 pages

Source:  Netgalley

Format:  ARC E-Book

Recommendation:  This book had much promise, but the details of the plot left me offended and speechless.  I cannot recommend this book.
SHARE ON: Share to Pinterest
Wednesday, February 8, 2017

Book Review: Champion by Marie Lu

https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/14290364-champion

Synopsis (From GoodReads):
June and Day have sacrificed so much for the people of the Republic—and each other—and now their country is on the brink of a new existence. June is back in the good graces of the Republic, working within the government’s elite circles as Princeps-Elect, while Day has been assigned a high-level military position.

But neither could have predicted the circumstances that will reunite them: just when a peace treaty is imminent, a plague outbreak causes panic in the Colonies, and war threatens the Republic’s border cities. This new strain of plague is deadlier than ever, and June is the only one who knows the key to her country’s defense. But saving the lives of thousands will mean asking the one she loves to give up everything.
  


Review:
It's taken me a while to start reading author Marie Lu's dystopian Legend series.  But once I started, I couldn't stop reading.  Champion is the third (and final) book in the series.  There is further world building, lots of action, forgiveness, and redemption that provides a satisfying conclusion to this story.

What I Liked:
World Building:
As with the other two books, the author has some great insights as to what future societies might look like.  We get the authoritarian government of The Republic, the privatized government of The Colonies, and now we see an entirely new social structure in Antarctica, based on technology and gaming!  I found each of these social systems plausible in the future, with definite downsides to each.  

Story:
Each character is confronted with a dilemma that will force them to choose between what they want personally, and what others want them to do.  Do our desires count for anything when they might conflict with what is best for society?  How can we reconcile these two conflicts?

I also loved the theme of forgiveness and redemption that ties each character's story together.  June is struggling to see if Day can ever forgive her for her involvement in the death of his mother.  Can they have a future together when June feels overwhelming guilt over what happened?  Can Day move from being a rebel against The Republic to supporting the government as they face invasion from other nations?  What can Anden do to make up for the sins of his father?  Is it too late?  Each person is forced to acknowledge that their lives may not lead to perfect, happy endings.

The Ending:
Obviously, I am not going to give away the ending, but I was very pleased with how things turned out.  It was not a fairy-tale finale.  There were sacrifices made by each character, but this made it more grounded, and plausible.

I especially liked that there was an epilogue so that you could see how everything turned out.

What I Didn't Like:
Once again, I was not a big fan of Commander Jameson.  She is not in many scenes, but I just never understood her motivation for being so over-the-top evil.  I really wish there had been some scenes of why she was so bitter.  Did she have a fling with Anden's dad that went sour?  Was she angry because she was not in a more powerful position?  We may never know.  What we do get is a Terminator-style final showdown where the Commander just keeps fighting, for no known reason.

As a whole, I really enjoyed all three books in this series.  With captivating characters, imaginative societies, and lots of action, this was a lot of fun to read.
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/14290364-champion

https://www.amazon.com/Champion-Marie-Lu/dp/014751228X/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1485753834&sr=8-1&keywords=marie+lu+champion

http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/champion-marie-lu/1115409400?ean=9780147512284

https://www.bookdepository.com/Champion-Marie-Lu/9780141339627?ref=grid-view


Rating: 




Release Date:  November 5th, 2013

Genre:  YA Dystopian

Source:  Public Library

Format:  Audio Book

Recommendation:  A satisfying end to the series.  The audio book versions of these books were very well produced with great performances by the actors.
SHARE ON: Share to Pinterest
Tuesday, August 2, 2016

ARC Review: Children Of Icarus by Caighlan Smith






Please Note:  I received an ARC copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.  This does not influence the opinions in my review in any way.

Synopsis (From GoodReads):
It is Clara who is desperate to enter the labyrinth and it is Clara who is bright, strong, and fearless enough to take on any challenge. It is no surprise when she is chosen. But so is the girl who has always lived in her shadow. Together they enter. Within minutes, they are torn apart forever. Now the girl who has never left the city walls must fight to survive in a living nightmare, where one false turn with who to trust means a certain dead end.

Review:
I was excited to read this book when I requested it from NetGalley.  But after I was approved, there was a note that said I could only access it as a protected PDF on my computer.  So no Kindle!  I would have to sit in an uncomfortable chair at my computer to read this.  I put it off, I made excuses, but then I finally settled in and opened the file...  And was sucked in!  This was a very scary, brutal, and yes, enjoyable tale.

I am going to attempt to write this spoiler-free, so here it goes.

What I Liked:

Setting:
Here is a wonderful case of "show not tell".  The novel shows a strange society where everyone lives their entire lives in giant apartment buildings, people worship Icarus, and (once a year) some children are Chosen.  They must leave the city to navigate the Icarus Maze in order to get emerge as Angels.  Why are they doing this?  Is the maze just a quick walk in a garden?  Why are these kids never heard from again?  The author does a great job of leading us down the primrose path!

Characters:  
Everyone here is very damaged, affected by the daily brutality of survival.  The kids appear to be kind, at first, but also scarred from the stress of trying to survive.  There is Elle, who befriends Clara (but is clearly mentally disturbed),  Ryan who instantly hates Clara for being a liability, and Collin, who thinks Clara is his long lost sister. 

There was also a mysterious character called The Executioner who appears and disappears, making you want to know her backstory.


What I Didn't Like:
 
Characters:
The main character, Clara, is shy, needy, and selfish.  She is often shown as a victim which I found upsetting.  She does grow over the story, but I found her lack of motivation to be annoying.  It was difficult for me to root for Clara when she didn't really try to be helpful through much of the book.  She was so passive that it was driving me crazy!  Don't you want to survive, girl?

Given that I found the main character, Clara, irritating, I can only give this book four stars.  But this novel did have a really great concept, other fascinating characters, and setting.


https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/29065483-children-of-icarus?ac=1&from_search=true
http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/children-of-icarus-caighlan-smith/1123639662?ean=9781630790578
https://www.amazon.com/Children-Icarus-Caighlan-Smith/dp/1630790575/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1468674789&sr=8-1&keywords=children+of+icarus


Rating: 



Release Date:  August 1st, 2016

Source:  NetGalley

Format:  Protected PDF (Boo!)

Recommendation:  If you enjoyed The Hunger Games, you will probably enjoy this violent tale of survival.  

 




   
SHARE ON: Share to Pinterest

GoodReads

2022 Reading Challenge

2022 Reading Challenge
MsArdychan has read 7 books toward her goal of 96 books.
hide

Badges

80% 80% 200 Book Reviews 2016 NetGalley Challenge
clean sweep 2017

Popular Posts

Grab My Button

http://ponderingtheprose.blogspot.com
<a href=“http://ponderingtheprose.blogspot.com" target="_blank" rel="nofollow"><img src="
http://ponderingtheprose.blogspot.com

Blogs I Follow

Search This Blog